Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Val Crosby's avatar

Mark Epstein is just going off on the wrong road. I'll read the report when it comes out but every piece of evidence he's revealed to us so far looks like he's hanging onto confirmation bias, starting with the Michael Baden nonsense (a "celeb pathologist" whose only apparent role in recent years has been to cast doubt on the official cause of every high-profile death).

The July 23 incident could have been a suicide attempt initially claimed as an attack by Epstein in order to isolate himself from his cellmate. And Nick Tartaglione told JRK that he told Epstein he wasn't going to allow Epstein to kill himself. Also if Nick was really serious about fighting his murder charges it makes little sense to attack another inmate, whatever his reputation.

Schulla's avatar

Hey Jay,

I just read your latest piece, the exclusive with Mark Epstein. Man, you really let him lay it all out there, and I appreciate you giving his side a platform. At the same time, after everything that’s come out, the full autopsy details, the DOJ Inspector General report, the FBI review. I believe that Epstein did kill himself. And I know how difficult it is for any loved one to accept these facts…

😥I will know. My dad killed himself in 2009, and for a long time I wanted to believe he was murdered because the truth was just too hard to reconcile with. It felt easier to think someone else took him from us than to sit with the pain of him choosing to end his own life.

I have nothing but empathy for Mark. Losing a brother in those circumstances, especially with all the jail screw-ups, has to be devastating. The negligence at the MCC was real and indefensible, guards asleep, falsified logs, no cellmate, broken cameras, bedding left in the cell. Those failures created the perfect storm for a desperate man to take his own life. But the forensic evidence (the ligature furrow matching the orange cloth, the petechiae pattern, the specific fractures consistent with hanging in a 66-year-old, and zero defensive wounds) still points to suicide, not murder.

You handled this with real integrity, Jay, giving Mark the mic while still laying out the documented facts.

I'm proud of the work you’re doing. Keep chasing the truth.

Your friend from Down Under

Schulla

No posts

Ready for more?